judy.legal
Login Register

PHILIP WACHIRA MWANIKI V. BLUESHIELD INSURANCE CO. LTD

(2002) JELR 95022 (CA)

Court of Appeal  •  Civil Application Nai. 13 of 2002  •  5 Jul 2002  •  Kenya

Coram
Johnson Evan Gicheru Emmanuel Okello O'Kubasu Moijo Matayia Ole Keiwua

Judgement

RULING OF THE COURT

In this Notice of Motion which is made under rule 80 ofthe Court of Appeal Rules, hereinafter called the Rules, theapplicant has sought to have the respondent's Notice of Appealdated 7th May, 1999 and date-stamped in the superior court on12th May, 1999 struck out for the reasons that the respondenthas since the lodgement of the said Notice of Appeal deliberately failed to institute its intended appeal against the decision of the superior court given on 6th May 1999 with the resultant delay in the conclusion of the litigation between them to his detriment.

According to the respondent, the proceedings and judgment relevant to its intended appeal were collected from the supEtiGan 8th May, 2001 but without certified copies of some documentary exhibits tendered in evidence in that court which allegedly had subsequently been collected by the then Counsel for the applicant in the superior court, Mr. F. N. Wamalwa

Efforts to retrieve these exhibits have not been successful.Hence the respondent's inability to lodge its intended appealagainst the decision of the superior court dated 6th May,1999. This notwithstanding, however, the respondent has notto date applied to a judge or registrar of the superior court for directions as to whether or not the missing documentary exhibits should be excluded from the record of appeal under

rule 85 (3) of the Rules. This lapse on the part of therespondent is inexcusable and disentitles it from relying on the missing documentary exhibits in the superior court for its inability to lodge its intended appeal within the prescribed period of sixty days of the date when the Notice of Appeal was lodged in the superior court - 12th May, 1999 - a period inexcess of two years. In these circumstances, the applicant's application to strike out the said Notice of Appeal is irresistible. The same is therefore granted with the result that the respondent's Notice of Appeal dated 7th May, 1999 and lodged in the superior court on 12th May, 1999 is struck out with costs to the applicant.

Dated and delivered at Nairobi this 5th day of July,2002.


J. E. GICHERU

..................

JUDGE OF APPEAL

E. O'KUBASU

..................

JUDGE OF APPEAL

M. Ole KEIWUA

..................

JUDGE OF APPEAL


I certify that this is

a true copy of the original.

DEPUTY REGISTRAR

There's more. Sign in to continue reading

judy.legal is the comprehensive database of case law and legislation from Ghana, Kenya and Nigeria. Gain seamless access to over 20,000 cases, recent judgments, statutes, and rules of court.


Get started   Login