REX V. EFFIONG EDET ITAH
JELR 81170 (WACA)
West Africa Court of Appeal
•
•
West Africa [For WACA cases]
Coram
COR. KINGDON, C.J., BUTLER LLOYD AND BAKER, JJ.
Appearances
J. I. C. Taylor for Appellant. E. H. Hunter for Crown.
Judgement
<p>KINGDON, C.J., NIGERIA, BUTLER LLOYD AND BAKER. JJ. The appellant was charged before Jackson, Assistant Judge, in the Calabar-Aba Judicial Division of the High Court upon 18 counts of âFraudulent False Accounting contrary to section 438 (b) of the Criminal Code â; the particulars given of the first count wert:</p><p>âThat Efiong Edet Itah on the 16th day of March, 1940, at âCalabar, in the Calabar Province, being a clerk or servant employed âby C.F.A.O., Calabar at its Edem Street. Branch Shop, Calabar with âintent to defraud made or was privy to making a false entry in a âbook of accounts belonging to his employer to wit theâ Recapitulation âdes Recettes et Rendementsâ purporting to show that on the said âday the total cost value of sundry goods sold at the said shop was âÂŁ13 5s whereas in truth and in fact it was ÂŁ11 58.â</p><p>The particulars under the other seventeen counts were of a similar nature. The appellant was convicted upon all 18 counts and was sentenced to 12 months I.H.L. upon each, the sentences to run concurrently.</p><p>The sole ground of appeal, is that the learned trial Judge misdirected himself in finding that there was intent to defraud. The facts and the Judgeâs reasons for convicting are best shown from the following extracts from his judgment:-</p><p>âThe accused was employed by Messrs Compagnie Francaise de â L Afrique Occidental as a sales clerk in their Branch Shop at Edem âStreet, Calabar. âThe prosecution bring evidence to show that on eighteen separate âoccasions, between March and December, 1940, the accused has made âfalse entries in one of the books of his employers, which it was his âduty to keep, namely the book known as the Recapitulation Book â(Exhibit No.2) by adding, on those occasions, to the true figure of âcost value of salesâ figures representing sums of money of even âdenominations of ÂŁ2, ÂŁ1 or l0s, thus making it appear that a larger ânumber of goods had been sold than was in fact the truth, and âshowing a smaller balance of stock in hand than was truly there, âor should be there. âMons. Chambon, the Agent of the Company has told me in most âemphatic terms that at no time did he authorize such false entries. âHe says that as a result of these false entries the Company has been âdeceived as to the true value of the stock which should properly âbe in the shop, and that as a result of this deceit the stock now âshows a deficiency. He admitted that deficiencies in stock in these âshops were not only quite normal, but that the Companyâs practice âwas to âwrite off â at the end of anyone year any such losses âprovided that they were not abnormal. He told me that he would ânot consider 1% of the annual turnover an abnormal shortage. âThere is no issue that the entries are false. The accused freely âadmits making these entries, but his defence is that there was no âintent to defraud as those entries were made, not only with the âapproval of Mons. Chambon, but were made by his direct instructions âas a system of showing âset offsâ in the âcash value of stocksâ âagainst âdashesâ made to regular customers from the stocks in the âshop. âMons. Chambon freely admitted that âdashesâ or commissions âhave been given habitually to regular customers, but he says that âsuch moneys are invariably accounted for in cash and not in stock. âHe tells me that the accusedâs duty was to deduct that âdashâ or âcommission from the âselling priceâ to the customer, for which the</p><p>âaccused having first obtained the Agentâs consent backed the gift âwith a âchitâ or voucher which he sent to the Cashier at the Head âOffice in Calabar, as an adjustment voucher, the sum totals of which âwere at the end of the month âset offâ â against the Shop Expenses. âThis witness, when cross-examined, was asked by defending âCounsel (Mr Anwan) if he could produce any such evidence of these âchitsâ. He said that he could, but that at no time had he been and</p><p>âasked to produce them. Mr Chambon, then, from documents which âhe had with him in the box handed several such chits to Mr Anwan â(which were admitted in evidence for the defence and marked as ââB â). Mons. Chambon added that if counsel wished him to produce âothers he could do so. Mr Anwan did not pursue the matter any âfurther. âThis witness testified that if goods were given from the shop as âdashes' they would have to be accounted for in the same way, i.e. âby a deduction to the customer from the âselling priceâ supported âby a â chitâ or voucher to the cashier at the Head Oftice.â âI now refer to those âchitsâ (Ex. B) which were put in evidence âand which have been proved to have been signed by the accused. âOne dated 10.4.40 âto be deducted from selling price to customer â68 âOne dated 13.4.40 to be deducted to customer ÂŁ2 12s âThus for that month is shown a total sum of ÂŁ2 18s 0d described by âthe Agent as âdashesâ or commission given by the accused with âhis approval. âOn turning to page 11 of Exhibit 31 I find recorded as âcommis âsion on salesâ the sum of ÂŁ2 18s 0d a figure brought to the notice âof the accused when a copy of that entry in this book is sent to him âat the end of each month. Similar corroborative evidence is afforded âby a study of the âchitsâ signed by the accused in September, 1940, âamounting to a sum of l1s 9d. The false figures inserted in the âRecapitulation Book are in every case even sums e.g. l0s, ÂŁ1 or on âone occasion ÂŁ2. âNow what occasion was there to set off âdashesâ or commission âby adding a figure to the âcost value of salesâ when it had already âbeen accounted for as a deduction from the selling price and set âoff against the Shop Expenses for those months?â âAfter hearing the evidence and after viewing the demeanour âof the witnesses I have no hesitation, whatsoever, in accepting the âevidence of Mons. Chambon and of rejecting and disbelieving that âof the accused. âNow the evidence before me shows that, in respect of each one âof the 18 counts with which the accused is charged, the accused âhas made a false entry in the Companyâs Recapitulation Book. âAgain, I re-iterate, the accused does not suggest that the entries âwere made other than by him and that he knew the quality of each âentry, but he denies that they are false, within the meaning of the âsection, as they were made with the full approval of his Agent. I , âhave already reviewed the evidence at, some length to say why I âbelieve that neither did Mons. Chambon approve of this method of</p><p>âaccounting, but that he had no knowledge that it was being done âuntil these entries were brought to his notice by the Auditor early âin January, 1941. âThus by making it appear that the sales of goods at cost priceâ âare greater than they actually were, the value of the stock which âshould be in the shop is reduced by the corresponding augmentation âof the sales value and thus either a loss of goods or a misappropria- âtion thereof is concealed whenever a check is madâ. âTo make a false entry in the Recapitulation Book by augmenting âthe âtotal value of cost salesâ was a negation of the system in vogue âfor accounting for such dashes, and was an act which was not only âunauthorized, but was one which left no record of the particular âtransaction, and was such as was likely to deceive his employers and âdid deceive his employers, resulting in a loss of stock which was only âdiscovered as the result of an independent audit. Why adopt this âirregular method of accounting when an approved one was in force, âand, one by which each item of âdashâ or commission had its record âin the system by way of vouchers and a set off âat the end of the âmonth of the total of these vouchers against the shop expenses?</p><p>âTo defraud is to deprive by deceit. Can this unauthorized âfalsification of accounts be termed anything other than deceit? I âthink not. Has the Company been deprived of anything by this âdeceit? It clearly has.</p><p>âIt has been deprived of its ability to obtain an accurate check âon the stock in the shop, by being led to believe by these false âentries that there was a smaller value of stock in the shop than âshould properly have been the case. In consequence a loss of stock âhas been occasioned.â</p><p>âWhen the gist of an offence is fraud, intent is material, and âevidence of other similar acts is admissible to prove that intent. âThe law to me is perfectly clear that if I, as a jury, am satisfied âthat these entries were unauthorized and were false to the knowledge âof the accused, the intent to defraud may be implied by me from âthose facts, and that where there is a consistent repetition of such âfalse entries, that is further evidence to prove the intent. I have been âasked to believe and to find that when the accused gave bottles of âbeer to customers as âdashesâ he set it off against the âtotal value âof cost salesâ. Why depart from a perfectly normal and straight- âforward method of accounting which was in existence during this âperiod? I disbelieve the accused that this was his practice for the âreasons already set out at some length in this judgmentâ</p><p>âI find that, at the time the accused made each one of the eighteen âfalse entries in his employerâs books, which are the subject of the counts âbefore me, he was a clerk employed by Messrs Compagnie Francaise âde Lâ Afrique Occidental at Calabar and that he made these false âentries with intent to defraud.â We are of opinion that there was ample evidence upon which the learned trial Judge could find that the appellant made the false entries with intent to defraud. It is admitted that the Company has been, in fact, deprived of goods to the various values indicated in the charges. The defence that these goods were given to customers by the appellant in the Companyâs interest and with the authority of the Companyâs Agent was disbelieved by the Judge and with good reason as the above extracts from his judgment show. In particular the exhibits B2-9 show that during the period covered by the charges the appellant was giving âdashesâ, getting approval for them, and accounting for them in the authorised manner; this is very strong evidence entitling the Judge to disbelieve the appellantâs story that it was with the Agentâs approval that he was carrying out concurrently a different system of giving other dashes, a system which afforded no check upon the amount of goods given away.</p><p>In arguing the appeal, counsel for the appellant has made much of a passage in the judgment not already quoted. It is â The accused may have given the witness, Efiong Ntibi, âdashesâ âof beer in âkindâ and there is no reason to disbelieve this fact â and I do accept itâ The Judge continued âbut, having done so, his duty of the manner in which he had to âaccount for the âdashâ by deducting the value of the âdashâ from âthe selling price and supporting it with a voucher for the value, âremained.â The witness, Efiong Ntibi, did testify that the appellant used to give him two bottles of beer extra when he bought a case, but it is remarkable that he was the only witness whom the appellant could bring to corroborate in any particular his story; and even Ntibi's evidence, accepted as it was by the Judge, does not show that the âdashesâ to him were not in fraud of the Company.</p><p>The appeal is dismissed.</p>