judy.legal
Login Register
đź“„ PDF

CHIEF FOSBERY LULU BRAIDE V. CHIFE OBU HARRY HORSFALL

JELR 83869 (WACA)

West Africa Court of Appeal  •   •  West Africa [For WACA cases]

🤖 BriefBot Summary

Coram
FOSTER-SUTTON, P., DE COMARMOND, Ag. C.J. (NIGERIA), AND COUSSEY, J.A.

Appearances
Chuba Ikpeazu for the Appellants. Dr Udo Udoma for the Respondents.

Judgement
<p>Foster Sutton, P. These proceedings were commenced by the Plaintiff/Respondent filing a Civil Summons in the Kalabari Native Court, Grade C, on the 5th June 1947, by which he claimed possession of a parcel of land situate in the Kalabari area and the sum of £300 for mesne profits.</p><p>On the 8th May, 1948, an Order of Transfer was made by the District Officer, under powers conferred by section 25 (1) (c) of the Native Courts Ordinance, No. 44 of 1933, now section 28 (1)( c ) of the Native Courts Ordinance, Cap. 142, transferring the suits for hearing in the Supreme Court.</p><p><sup class='page-numbering' title='Page 49'>*Page 49</sup> The case eventually came for trial before Thomas, J, in the Supreme Court of the Port Harcourt Judicial Division, on the 10th March, 1954, and on the 16th July, 1954, judgment was given for the plaintiff for possession of the land in dispute and for the sum of £200 as mesne profits. It is against that judgment that the defendant –appellant has appealed.</p><p>The only point seriously argued before us was a submission by appellant’s Counsel that as section 8 (2) of Cap. 142 and the Schedule, which are reproductions of the 1933 Ordinance, provide that the jurisdiction of a Native Court Grade “C”, shall be limited in civil actions to claims in which the debt, demand or damages do not exceed fifty pounds, the Native Court in question had no jurisdiction to issue a Civil Summons claiming the sum of £300, and that the whole proceedings must, therefore, be regarded as a nullity. The point was not raised during the trial in the Court below, and we only allowed it to be argued before us because if the point were sound the Civil Summons would have had to be regarded as a nullity and the trial Court would then have had no jurisdiction to entertain the case.</p><p>The proviso to section 12 of the Supreme Court Ordinance, 211, provides, inter alia, that “except in so far as the Governor in Council may by order otherwise direct and except in suits transferred to the Supreme Court under the provisions of section 25 (in error for section 28) of the Native Court Ordinance, the Supreme Court shall not exercise original jurisdiction in any suit which raises any issue as to the title to land or as to the title to any interest in land which is subject to the jurisdiction of a Native Court”.</p><p>It seems clear, therefore, that the legislature, generally speaking intended suits involving claims in respect of native land, as distinct from ordinary monetary claims to be tried by the Native Courts. One good reason for this policy is that so many of such claims involve questions of native law and custom.</p><p>The relevant portions of section 8 of the Native Courts Ordinance reads as follows:- “(1) Every native court shall have jurisdictions and power, to the extent set forth in its warrant</p><p>(2) For the purposes of the preceding subsection the Governor may by order grade native courts and prescribe the jurisdiction and power which is to be set forth in the warrants for the native courts of each grade”.</p><p>Except in so far as the Governor may be such an order otherwise direct, there shall be four grades of Native Courts, namely grades A,B,C and D, and the jurisdiction and power which shall be set forth in the warrants of native courts of these grades not, without the permission of the Governor, exceed those prescribed in the Schedule hereto”, and the relevant portion of the Schedule reads: “Grade C –In the Southern Provinces such jurisdiction in causes concerning land or in which the title to land or any interest therein comes in question, as may be stated in the warrant or annexure thereto”. The powers conferred upon the Governor by subsection (2) were subsequently delegated to Chief Commissioners.</p><p>Had the point been taken in the Court below Counsel for the respondent would, no doubt have caused the warrant of the Kalabari Native Court to be produced but since the point was not taken there was no reason why he should have done so.</p><p>It seemed to us, however, that the warrant of the Court was a matter we could take Judicial notice of, and we accordingly caused the warrant of the Kalabari Native Court, Grade C, to be produced for our inspection.</p><p>That warrant was confirmed on the 23rd day of March, 1938, by the then Acting Chief Commissioner, Southern Provinces and it confers upon the Native Court in question unlimited jurisdiction in “Causes concerning land, or in which the title to land or any interest therein comes in question, providing that the land lies wholly within the area of the jurisdiction of the Court”. It was not suggested in this case that the land did not lie wholly within the jurisdiction of the Native Court concerned. </p><p>The Chief Commissioner clearly had power to confer the jurisdiction stated in the warrant, and it seems to me that it is beyond argument that the whole of the claim in this case was a cause concerning land. It was claim for possession of the land, and a claim for the profits wrongly collected from the land by the defendant.</p><p>Counsel for the respondent drew our attention to the decision of this Court in Civil Appeal No.3761, reported in Selected Judgments August, October-November, 1952, at p. 61,(1) which he contended supported his submission that a Native Court C cannot entertain an action for any money claim which exceeds £50.</p><p>The record of this Court in that case makes it quite clear that we declined to entertain a cross appeal by the respondent, which sought to have reinstated an award of damages, since both Counsel in the Court of trial had agreed that the Native Court there under consideration had no jurisdiction to entertain the monetary claim, and the reference in the judgment of this Court to the money claim was only by the way of narrative. It follows that the case in question has no bearing on the issue we have to determine in the present appeal.</p><p>For the reasons given I find no difficulty in reaching the conclusion that the Kalabari Native Court had jurisdiction to issue the Civil Summons in this case, and I would accordingly dismiss this appeal with costs fixed at £33-2s-0d.</p><p>De Comarmond, Ag. C.f. I concur.</p><p>Coussey, f. A. I concur.</p><p>Appeal dismissed.</p>

There's more. Sign in to continue reading

judy.legal is the comprehensive database of case law and legislation from Ghana, Kenya and Nigeria. Gain seamless access to over 20,000 cases, recent judgments, statutes, and rules of court.


Get started   Login