SAMUEL N. THOMAS V. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
JELR 83452 (WACA)
West Africa Court of Appeal
•
•
West Africa [For WACA cases]
Coram
VERITY, C.J. (NIGERIA), AMES AND RHODES, JJ.
Appearances
A wolowo for Appellant. Amachee, Crown Counsel, for Respondent.
Judgement
<p>Ames, J. This appeal is against a conviction in the Magistrate’s Court. Ibadan, for stealing ., 93 Ibadan Race Club Tote Tickets value £46 10s. 0d.”, That Race Club had a two-day” Summer Meeting” on 24th August and 4th September of last year. The appellant was one of the two persons selling Tote Tickets (as they were called by the witnesses} for the Race Club to the public who attended the meeting. He did so on both days. The charge referred to the latter day. It was proved, very clearly indeed, that, in some of the books of tickets given to him to sell on 4th September, a few of the tickets had been removed from the bottom of the book, instead of from the top downwards serially, and that the total of these was 93 ten shilling tickets, and the £4610s. 0d., which ought to have been with the rest of the cash received by the appellant for sales of tickets, was not with it and instead £40 was found in two of his pockets. There were also proved many other details, which need not be set out here, such for example, that the appellant had been selling tote tickets for fourteen years and so knew well the procedure in connection with the tote.</p><p>One of the two grounds of appeal is that it was wrong in law to hold that on the evidence the appellant stole or fraudulently converted the tickets. The argument is that he was given the tickets to sell and he dia sell them, and that if any offence was committed at all it was in respect of the cash received for the tickets and not in respect of the actual tickets themselves. We find no substance in this argument; there was the clearest evidence to indicate that when he removed these tickets from the books he did so with animus furandi and that he intended to use them for his own purposes and not for the purpose for which the Race Club gave him the possession of the tickets (but not the property in them) 4 and that he did so use them by converting them into cash, which he pocketed. Whatever may be the case under English Law, this is clearly stealing in this country, because it is within the provisions of sections 383 (1), (2) and (4).</p><p>Evidence was given for the prosecution that on 24th August also some ten shilling tickets had been removed from the bottom of the books of tickets issued to the appellant for sale (in distinction from those issued to the other seller); and the other ground of appeal refers to this and is that this evidence was in admissible. Objection was taken to it at the time, but the learned Magistrate overruled it, and the learned Judge of the Supreme Court who heard the appeal also held that it was admissible. In our opinion also it was clearly admissible.</p><p>We were referred to the judgment of the Privy Council in the case of Noor Mohamed (1) which is the most recent statement of the law on this point to be made by an ultimate Court of Appeal and in which the principal modern leading cases were considered. Since the time of Makin's case (2), it has been well settled that evidence tending to show the commission of some offence, not the subject of the charge then being tried, is not admissible to prove a general or special criminal tendency on the part of the accused or to “reinforce” (to borrow Mr. Awolowo’s apt word) the rest of the evidence. But evidence of previous acts or incidents similar to the one charged is admissible as evidence for the prosecution for certain well-known purposes, such as proof of guilty knowledge or intention, or that the act was intentional’ and not accidental or to rebut certain defences and so on. Such evidence is then relevant.</p><p>The learned Magistrate in overruling the objection to the evidence relied on section 8 of the Evidence Ordinance without saying for what particular purpose he regarded it as relevant; nor did he mention the particular purpose in his judgment.</p><p>At the hearing of the appeal to the Supreme Court the learned Judge held that it was admissible because it led up to and explained the great care taken by the manager of the Tote in his examination, custody and marking of the books of tickets issued to the appellant on 4th September and also to rebut the defence that the missing tickets might have been taken by the manager’s servants.</p><p>We certainly agree with the latter of these reasons (and so need not consider the former). It was part of the appellant's defence that the manager's servants could have taken the missing tickets and, as his Counsel said in his address to the Magistrate “evidence has been led that (the manager's) gardener and steward had access to the box. One helped (the manager) to take the box to the race course” . AU the missing tickets of 4th September had been taken from the books issued to the appellant, and it was unlikely that any servant (or other person) with access to all the books would by chance have helped himself to tickets only from books afterwards issued to the appellant; and evidence that the same had been the case also on the former occasion virtually ruled out this defence. The evidence was thus relevant and admissible.</p><p>In conclusion we would add this. Even had we been of opinion that this evidence was wrongly admitted, we would not have allowed the appeal for that reason. The evidence about.4th September was by itself such as to leave no possible doubt as to the guilt of the appellant.</p><p>The result is that the appeal is dismissed on both grounds. </p><p>Appeal dismissed.</p>