THE SHELL PETROLEUM DEVELOPMENT COMPANY OF NIGERIA LIMITED V. OJIOWHOR MONDAY AMADI ELDER GEORGE AMADI CHIEF FELIX O. NJOE NWANWA CHIEF AMOBI WALL ELDER AZUBULKE NWANWA PRINCE COLLINS AMADI PRINCE EMMANUEL ENWANWA PRINCE RAYMOND AMADI PRINCE MORGAN AMADI EZE GOEFRREYA. A. NWANWA ELDER CHUKWUNENYE AMOS AMADI DEACON HOWELLS AWANWA HON. PRINCE ADELE WALL (SUING FOR THEMSELVES AND ON BEHALF OF THE RUMUCHETA-MGBUESILARU FAMILY OF OKPORO RUMUKOROSHE TOWN IN THE OBIO/AKPOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA OF RIVERS STATE) V. CHIEF LUKE IHUNWO ELDER FRANKLIN NYEBUCHI IWEZOR CHIEF FELIX AMADI CHIEF LAZARUS E. AMADI ELDER EMMANUEL H. AMADI OKIOWHOR JOSEPH AMADI OJIOWHOR G. A. IWEZOR ELDER EMMANUEL IWEZOR MR. HUMPHREY IWEZOR CHIEF PRINCEWILL IWEZOR MR. AUGUSTINE IHUNWO CHIEF INNOCENT IHUNWO MR. BRIGHT IHUNWO ELDER GODFREY AMADI HON. KENNETH IWEZOR (SUING FOR THEMSELVES AND ON BEHALF OF THE RUMUKURU-MGBUESILARU FAMILY OF OKPORO TOWN IN THE OBIO/AKPOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA OF RIVERS STATE) V. CHIEF EMMANUEL AZUBUIKE ELDER SAMUEL OLUMATI ROYAL OBIDI V. THE GOVERNMENT OF RIVERS STATE OF NIGERIA V. PRINCE AUSTIN ENWANWA MR. PRECIOUS WALI PRINCE AZUNDA AMADI
(2010) JELR 56397 (CA)
Court of Appeal
•
CA/PH/51/2008
•
15 Apr 2010
•
Nigeria
Coram
SULEIMAN GALADIMA JCA (Presided) ISTIFANUS THOMAS JCA EJEMBI EKO JCA (Read the Lead Judgment)
Appearances
Chief T. J. O. Okpoko, SAN (with him, Chief O. Akani, SAN, O. J. Irerhime, Esq., H. I. Dike, Esq., A. E. Aperua-Yusuf Esq. and Dike
-*-
Udenna, Esq.) - for the Appellant. C
-*-
L. E. Nwosu, Esq., SAN (with him, E. E. Asido, Esq., G. W. Iwezor, Esq., S. Azubuike, Esq., and D. E. Ekenna, Esq.) - for 1st and 2nd sets of Respondents.
-*-
Alhaji F. A. Oso, SAN (with him, E. O. Nwobiri, Esq., and S. A. Lawal, Esq.) - for 3rd set of Respondents. D
-*-
O. S. Elisanmi, Esq., State Counsel, Ministry of Justice, Rivers State
-*-
- for 4th set of Respondents.
Judgement
EKO JCA (Delivering the Lead Judgment): The parcel of land containing an approximate area of 153.5 acres lying and situate at Mgbuesilaru (Ngbusilaru) abutting in Rumuokwurusi described in a tenancy deed dated 3 March 1958, delineated particularly in a plan No BAN/112/57 was leased to the 2nd defendant, now the appellant, by the Rumuecheta-Mgbuesilaru and Umukurukuru-Mgbuesilaru families of Okporo-Rumukoroshe village of Rivers State. The appellant, as the tenant, was to hold the demised parcel of land for a term of 99 years from 9 February 1957 and to be: paying to the lessors upon the execution of these presents the sum of £2,686.5 - (two thousand, six hundred and eighty-six pounds, five shillings) representing ten (10) years rent in advance, the receipt of which the lessors hereby acknowledge, and thereafter without demand on 9 February in each subsequent year as from February 1967 the said annual rent of £268,12.6d (two hundred and sixty-eight pounds, twelve shillings and six pen…